Rich western urbanites expecting to dodge the impacts of climate change should prepare for a jolt: global warming is leading to bad, expensive coffee. Almost 2bn cups of coffee perk up its drinkers every day, but a perfect storm of rising heat, extreme weather and ferocious pests mean the highland bean is running out of cool mountainsides on which it flourishes.
"The rise in global temperature is of great concern for us in the coffee industry because it will – and has already started – putting the supply of quality coffee at great risk," said Dr Tim Schilling, executive director of the World Coffee Research programme, based at Texas A&M University. "It is also obvious that increasing temperatures – as well as extreme weather events – have a very negative affect on production. Over the long term, you will definitely see coffee prices going up as a result of climate change."
Mauricio Galindo, head of operations at the intergovernmental International Coffee Organisation, is equally worried: "Climate change is the biggest threat to the industry. If we don't prepare ourselves we are heading for a big disaster." Coffee drinkers may see the effect in their cups, but the 25m rural households around the globe whose livelihoods depend on coffee will be hit far harder.
The world's foremost climate science group, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), will include the effect of warming on coffee as part of a landmark report published next Monday on the global impacts of climate change. It is expected to conclude: "The overall predictions are for a reduction in area suitable for coffee production by 2050 in all countries studied. In many cases, the area suitable for production would decrease considerably with increases of temperature of only 2.0-2.5C."
The IPCC will report that in Brazil, the world's biggest coffee producer, a temperature rise of 3C would slash the area suitable for coffee production by two-thirds in the principal growing states of Minas Gerais and São Paulo and eliminate it in others. While growing will become possible in states further south, this will not compensate for losses further north. An IPCC report on the science of climate change published in September projected the world will warm by 2.6-4.8C by the end of the century without deep cuts in greenhouse gas emissions.
The dangers to coffee stem from its origins in the highlands of east Africa, where the relatively cool and stable climate found between 1,500-2,800m allows the berries to thrive. But at 23C and above, the plant's metabolism starts to race, leading to lower yields and, crucially, a failure to accumulate the right mix of aromatic volatile compounds that deliver coffee's distinctive taste.
Worse, pests like the berry borer beetle and leaf rust fungus are flourishing as the world warms. Leaf rust has already savaged recent harvests in the coffee heartlands of central America, with yields down 40% in 2013-14 compared to 2011-12. "The only way you can make sense of it is through climate change," said Galindo. "The temperature has risen and this fungus can attack with a speed and aggression we have never seen." At least 1.4 million people in Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras and Nicaragua depend on coffee production for their livelihoods. When coffee's susceptibility to changes in climate has caused crises in the last few decades, a quarter of all households have been forced to migrate.
The pest, berry borer beetle, was unknown until about 2000 in Ethopia, Uganda, Burundi and Rwanda, as it preferred the warmer temperatures at lower altitudes. But warming has driven the beetles up the hillsides and into the coffee plantations and it now causes $500m damage a year. The beetle currently reproduces five times a year but further warming is expected see that to rise to 10 times. Endosulfan, the pesticide once used to control the berry borer, was banned in 2011.
Climate change is also increasing the frequency of extreme weather events, as more energy is trapped in the atmosphere. According to Galindo, 2014's severe drought in Brazil has shown how sensitive prices are to such climate impacts, with the price doubling to $2 per pound, even before the harvest.
Assessing all the combined impacts of climate change, Galindo said: "In the worst-case scenario, we will only have a few places producing coffee." Brazil, Vietnam, Indonesia, Columbia and Ethiopia are the biggest producers and will probably have the resources to attempt to adapt, he said. "But central America and Laos and Peru and Burundi and Rwanda, they are gone."
The IPCC report will state that in some places, such as Uganda, adaptation by shifting plantation up hillsides will be impossible: they will simply reach the top and run out of land. Efforts are being made to develop new coffee varieties, to tolerate higher temperatures and resist pests. The coffee industry was worth $173bn in 2012, but Galindo said: "You need major financial means to change all your trees." Lab-based genetic engineering, like that used to insert pest-killing toxins into maize and cotton, has been ruled out by the industry due to consumer opposition.
"But the real genetic variety of coffee has never really been exploited," Schilling said. For arabica coffee, 70% of the world market, "every plant derives from only two or three Ethiopian varieties from 2,000 years ago", he said. Researchers are now working to identify the 10 or 20 most genetically diverse coffee plants from 1,000 native varieties collected in the Ethiopian forests in the 1960s by the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation, with the results expected later in 2014.
These can then be crossed and put into field trials to develop what Schilling calls "super races" of coffee. Once identified, conventional techniques can quickly deliver millions of plants.
"I am very optimistic this strategy will produce the plants we need," Schilling said. "But the weak point is the time available. It is a race – if we had started 10 years ago, we would be very confident that today we would have tools to battle climate change. But I wonder if coffee growers will be able to withstand climate change for another 10 years."
View all comments >
comments (180)
Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion.
This discussion is closed for comments.
We’re doing some maintenance right now. You can still read comments, but please come back later to add your own.
Commenting has been disabled for this account (why?)
Twenty quid says it'll be ok.
On what basis are you so confident?
Seems to me they can grow coffee away from the tropics and on higher elevations IF it does get warmer. I look at the current trend and I don´t see much surface warming taking place until the 2030´s. By then they can probably make coffee grow in Scotland.
At the moment all coffee is grown in the band between the Tropic of Cancer and the tropic of Capricorn.
Oh no. Much more expensive, oh no!!
Worse. I'm going to have some very bad mornings!
Don't worry, Paracetemol Plus has caffine in it - so it takes care of the hangover too.
Ah, but it's not available in Ontario.
I don't need a hangover cure, but mornings need coffee!
And the fact that every day of the week 200,000 more potential coffee drinkers are born doesn't play a role in price rises???
What a limited amount of arable land it might be more important to grow food on the land that once was used for coffee which is after all not a product of basic necessity like water or cereals.
Arabica coffee's are grown at altitude 1300 m to 1500 m generally (very hilly)
and are picked buy hand in regions of the world with very poor road infrastructure if any roads at all so good luck on that.
Why not cancel out wine less people drink than coffee?
Sorry should say.
Less people drink wine than coffee.
There's a wine shortage on the way already.
Everything is economics now, coffee and morality and climate.
Very well said - if I could give you more than one UpRon then I would. I do love my coffee in the morning (and afternoon) but it's not high up on the list of reasons of why I want a change in strategy on energy use.
Coffee is jeapardy?
Ok. Now I'm concerned.
You joke, but I suspect articles in the food and gardening sections of newspapers are far more likely to shift the debate in favour of action than any socially aware article in the Guardian about entire cities being destroyed in the Philippines. The people who care about the troubles of foreigners, or who see science as something more than a scam perpetrated by schoolteachers, have long been converted already.
It just needs to appear in the Daily Telegraph or Daily Mail, rather than the Guardian.
This infers coffee is the thing that will finally make people act. How stupid.
Coffee as a commodity, is second only to oil.
That is a bit nebulous it is probably better to say.
Coffee is the second most valuable commodity exported by developing countries.
It's a big deal one way or another to many coffers.
This issue - climate change impact on coffee production- has been known for years. Unfortunately, we don't take things serious enough until it is too late and/or very expensive to mitigate. Hopefully the coffee industry now reacts and starts supporting more decisively adaptation measures in the coffee farmer communities + research into new plant material.
I got the sense that coffee will be fine. For example, here´s a temperature plot for land temperatures
Most Excellent Plot of Global Surface Temperatures (Land) from Berkeley Earth website
As you can see land temperatures increased by about 1 degree C in a century. But this didn´t necessarily hurt worldwide coffee crops. Evidently those small coffee growing áreas where they cant move uphill or lack geographic breadth they will grow less coffee unless they change their seeds. But new areas can be planted, and it´s easy to move up hill to lose 1 degree C. I think the article is much ado about nothing. I would worry much more about damages to the rice crop.
Robusta, cheap poor quality supermarket imitation coffee
For anyone interested in the subject of man-made climate change and how useless so far the response of present international governments is to this threat, read James Lovelock's 'The Revenge of Gaia' and 'The Vanishing Face of Gaia'.
IThe two books are a real eye opener as to how the effects of climate change are irreversible now, even if we do make severe carbon emission cuts, as a tipping point has already been reached.
He definitely knows his stuff. It's a crime the politicians have ignored him. Britain could have led the world into a technologically advanced, but green and equal future. Instead we have just the new capitalism, debt, the hopeless pursuit of growth and lying politicians.
This from The Geological Society of London:
https://www.geolsoc.org.uk/About/Working-for-the-Society/~/~/link.aspx?_id=7A3775341F8B4861804751D98FADB7BA&_z=z
is truly disturbing.
It's a bit technical for some, but persist - every bit is important.
Good link and scary
Ten years to develop new climate resistant varieties for coffee is a pipe-dream.
They have hardly started and new coffee varieties take about 20 years.
There are no magic bullet solutions and proffering one like this is dangerous - the industry might think it's all being taken care of.
It saddens me that such threats to our western decadent lifestyles seem to be the only way of waking anyone up.
It's time to wake up and smell the coffee, before it's gone.
Drinking coffee to you is a decadent lifestyle?
Bluecloud is right - coffee, and any number of other exploitative foods that are luxuries but which many people consider necessities, are part of the decadent and wasteful life of the west (or the global North, looked at another way).
Any sane regime would begin to tax, restrict and ultimately ban foods and drinks which have excessive caffeine, sugar, fat, alcohol, additives, chemicals and salt, and which incur too many food miles. To that end, we need the Greens in power, asap.
Coffee is really no more than an addictive drug. Ideally we should all be drinking moderate amounts of water, and stick to that.
What a miserable existence that would be Chloe (restricted to water).
Thankfully we live in a democracy where the electorate overwhelmingly reject the Green Party come election time, time and time again.
I would go as far as to say, Lucas will lose her seat at the election and the Green Council losing control in Brighton, given the complete mess they have made, and the publics immense dislike of them.
We're fucked, coffee is the least of our problems.
Glaciers shlaciers.
Polar bears - who cares?
Low-lying city - what a pity.
COFFEE under threat AArrrrgghhhhh!
Really, Guardian? This is some kind of Guardian bingo full house, surely?
Tell em climate change will lead to more immigrants, and benefit claimants, and you'll get a bit more interest from the wider reading public.
Didn't stop you reading it, or did you skip straight to the comments?
Nah that's the Daily Mail mate or the Sun.
I think your lost.
No, not interested in coffee that has been genetically engineered. Would give that a wide berth, absolutely.
But grafting and cross pollination to produce hybrids is likely to be more acceptable to the public.
More expensive? Hope not; but even so, will still savour it. May have to have less, but will enjoy it more.
Sounds like a good opportunity for MonSatano and GME.
Here at Monsanto, we have an ecosystem of products that put your business ahead of shifting biomes and emerging trends.
Please take all my future earnings and place them in a tax haven.
It's the least I can do.
Only in the Guardian!
I better stock up then.
In Vietnam, now the 2nd largest world exporter of coffee, most of the exported coffee is Robusta, not Arabica. Most would say it's a lower-quality product, I would agree, but it is more adaptive to different climates. So the article would be more correct to talk about how the type of coffee people prefer is harder to grow . . .
correct but climate change is likely affect robusta growing zones as well and test its resilience in ways the plant has not experienced
I've drunk Vietnam's highest grade Robusta it's rough as F**k.
Robusta has roughly double the amount of caffeine content of Arabica.
A lot of Italian espresso blend's contain Robusta it gives a better crema than just Arabica.
Crema is the caramel, golden yellow layer of oils you should see on the top of a shot of espresso ( like the head on a Guinness)
tevist
Any thoughts about Vietnamese coffee and Agent Orange?
We can start by carrying our own reusable mugs for coffee, instead of the paper cups that are not compostable by and large with their plastic lids.
Have you calculated the extra calorific energy needed for a person to lift and carry their own personal mug around with them all day? And what about the additional weight taking it's toll on the fuel usage for transportation? An interesting proposal, but I think the scientists need to crunch the numbers on this one.
The lifting and shifting energy is in the noise, irrelevant (and you need the exercise). What is important is the energy (or oil) needed to make ceramics (or plastics), compared with a disposable paper cup. Basically, if you can commit to keeping the thing in use for *years* (about 5) then it's beneficial to re-use. But if you are, like, it's my birthday so I'll buy a new mug, then we lose.
And paper means wood chips.
If you want to be green and mean it, just don't drink coffee. I gave it up years ago. Felt much better mentally and physically when I did. Saved money and slept better.
You won't miss it. Just be prepared for the headache you may have for 2-3 days as you withdraw.
pah! It's tough up north .... london
Climate change does not exist. Nigel ("Let them drink beer") Farage says so!
And Nigel Lawson.
Is it something about people called Nigel?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXNhL4J_S00
'Let them drink beer' - sounds like an election winning slogan.
and play Bingo!
Cant have this,that's half the high street shut down without coffee!!!
Just leaves banks with machines inside/outside,charity shops,and I hate agents,sorry,estate agents......
You forgot hairdressers.
And tattoo parlors!
for more on the climate change/coffee story check out Jimmy Doherty on excellent C4 Food Prices film earlier this week
http://www.channel4.com/programmes/food-prices-the-shocking-truth/4od
Is this what was holding up the signatures on that climate change summary document?
First Gove ruins one of my favourite songs for me, now this!
Aside from the migration of insects, there may be an additional effect at play in the future:
During similar episodes of rapid climate change in the geological past, insect consumption of plant leaves increased. This may be due to a decrease in the nutritional content of plant matter as a function of increased atmospheric CO2.
Indeed, also having watched a report on fungal growth which is ravaging Banana plantations globally, again because of climate change, our staple crops are becoming vulnerable.
"Society is only three square meals away from revolution"
The Chinese would say were are living in interesting times.